Your pizza looks done on top. Then you lift a slice and find a pale, soft base. The oven was hot, but the pan under the dough did not pass heat to it fast enough.
Verdict: If you make round pizza often, try a steel in the oven you own before buying another oven. Choose an Ooni when the very hot, fast bake is the point. Keep your pan if it already makes the pizza you like.
Start with the base
A sheet pan warms the dough more gently than a steel. A pizza stone holds heat, but steel passes it to the dough faster. That can help a pale base. It can also burn a thin base if you use too much heat, so check the underside as the top cooks.
A steel works in the oven you have
A steel is a heavy slab that sits on an oven rack. Baking Steel’s method sets the oven to 500 to 550F and gives a thin pizza about 4 to 6 minutes. A quarter-inch slab is a place to start. The 16 by 14.25 inch Artisan Steel gives you more room to land a pizza, but it weighs 16 pounds. The 13 inch square Hans Grill takes less rack space and leaves less room around a wide pie. Measure your oven rack and think about where you will store the slab.
An outdoor oven makes a different pizza
Most home ovens stop near 500 to 550F. A few new ranges have hotter pizza modes, but most readers do not own one. Ooni rates the gas Ooni Koda 2 Pro to 950F. Ooni says it can cook an 18 inch Neapolitan-style pizza in as little as 60 seconds. A steel in a home oven cannot make that same soft, charred crust. You do need outdoor space, fuel, and practice turning the pie. Ooni says not to put a steel in its ovens.
Both surfaces need time between pies
A steel spends stored heat on the first pizza and needs time to recover; Baking Steel’s own fix for a crowd is a second steel. An Ooni stone also loses surface heat between pies, which is why Ooni advertises faster burner recovery on the Koda 2 generation. Neither is automatically a party machine.
Pick for the pizza you make
Pan pizza: Use the oven and pan you own. Try a full preheat and a higher rack before you buy anything.
Round pizza most weeks: A steel may fix a pale base without taking up more counter space. Check the weight and fit first.
Very hot, fast pizza: An outdoor oven is worth a look if you have the space and want to learn its heat and timing.
Who should skip a steel
Skip the steel if you make pan pizza now and then and already like it. It is heavy to move and store. If Neapolitan pizza is the only style you want, look at the outdoor oven first. A steel cannot turn your home oven into one.
Think about your next pizza night. If the base is pale, try the steel. If your pan pizza is good, keep the pan. Give the Ooni a place only when you want the very hot bake enough to make room for it.
Cited sources
- Baking Steel, home-oven method
- Ooni, Koda 2 Pro specifications
- Ooni, Pizza Steel use guidance



