A steak can look done before the center is ready. An indoor grill with a leave-in thermometer lets you follow that center without repeatedly lifting the lid or cutting into dinner. That is the DG551’s strongest reason to occupy your counter.

Verdict: Choose the Ninja Foodi Smart XL DG551 for regular indoor steak, chicken, or pork cooking when an outdoor grill is impractical. The probe and a generous grate make a useful combination. It weighs roughly 24 pounds and leaves several greasy parts to clean. If you mainly need an air fryer, or already use a pan and thermometer well, you may not need another large appliance.

The probe tracks dinner; it does not cook by itself

Ninja advertises 4 protein settings and 9 doneness levels. The connected thermometer monitors internal temperature while the grill cooks. That is more useful for a thick piece of meat than guessing from surface color or a timer alone.

TechRadar tested the DG551 specifically and reported good browning, with prompts to add, turn, and remove food. The reviewer also used the thermometer to target doneness. That is encouraging, but your cut and its thickness still matter.

Read the probe-placement instructions before the first cook. The probe has to reach the right part of the meat. Put it in the wrong place and the display can mislead you. Check your first few results with an instant-read thermometer. Learn how each preset and the resting time affect the result, then note the settings you like.

Ninja describes a 500°F grate and circulating hot air. Expect contact browning and grill marks. You will not get the combustion flavor of charcoal or wood simply because the word grill is on the box.

XL capacity shares one heat setting

Ninja says the grate fits up to 6 steaks or 24 hot dogs. That depends on their size. The broad grate is useful for several pieces of similar thickness.

It has no separate heat zones. TechRadar had to add vegetables after meat and sometimes remove them early. If asparagus needs less time than a thick steak, the thermometer does not settle that disagreement. You still manage the side dish.

The included crisper basket holds 4 quarts. You can also air fry, roast, bake, broil and dehydrate. Count the modes that would replace a job you already do. A list of 6 functions does not turn one cooking cavity into 6 appliances working at once.

Give it a permanent place, then clean it

Ninja lists it at 18.74 inches long, 17.95 inches wide and 14.45 inches high. It weighs 24.03 pounds. Use those figures to plan the counter space, then allow room to raise the lid. Older reviews give different measurements.

Grease is the continuing commitment. The pot, grate, basket, and removable splatter shield can go in the dishwasher. Ninja lists the shield as a DG551-compatible part. It protects the heating element and helps limit smoke. It sits above the food, so remember to clean it too.

TechRadar also notes Ninja’s recommendation for high smoke-point oils such as canola or avocado, rather than olive oil. Oil choice and cleaning affect the indoor experience. Less smoke does not mean a smoke-free kitchen.

Who should skip it

Before buying, measure the open-lid space and imagine washing the cooking parts after your ordinary Tuesday dinner. If those tasks fit, the probe gives this grill a clear job. If they do not, a pan and the thermometer you already own deserve another chance.

Cited sources


More field guides

More Precision Chef guides

All Precision Chef guides